A common form of film adaptation is the use of a novel as the basis of a feature film. Joyce carol oates story where are you going, where have you been, tom. Benedict cumberbatch to star in how to stop time for. Oates wrote an essay about the adaptation, where are you going, where have you been. The film would have strictly been an adaptation piece, or an attempt at a nontranslatable adaptation in this example. Where are you going, where have you been adaptation casting. V for vendetta should be next in line for an hbo adaptation cbr. We observe that the word symbols in written language must be translated into images of things, feelings and concepts through the process of thought. Get an answer for in the film smooth talk based on where are you going, where have you been. What film adaptation was as good as or better than its. Although its soul is comic, and it indulges in shameless invention, it is also the most accurate film i have seen about this process exaggerated, yes, but true. The looking for alaska film adaptation is not going well. Joyce carol oatess where are you going, where have you been.
Author celeste ng discuss adapting little fires everywhere book for screen, what she hopes viewers take away from the story and the stories important underlying themes. Greta gerwig on her little women film adaptation nprs michel martin speaks with. The greatest movie adaptations of books classic fm. Based on joyce carol oates short story, the film follows connie, a 15 year old girl through her life and summer in 1966. James bond has been played by a variety of different actors featuring several different plotlines but has continued to be an extremely popular franchise with audiences. You have been appointed gosh, gods assistant for smaller, less serious everyday business. What film adaptation was as good as or better than its source material. Despite the worldwide success, some of the films are known to have been severely cut and have a lot of missing details that the fans would have liked. The movie smooth talk which is based on the short story where are you going, where have you been has many similarities. Harper lees debut and so far only published novel has sold over 30 million copies and the film is a faithful adaptation of her story. Hed been hired to adapt the susan orlean book the orchid thief, about her experiences with rare flower hunter john laroche, into a film, only to find out it had no real story and was mostly about flowers. Where are you going, where have you been adaptation. Mar 14, 2017 benedict cumberbatch is attached to star in how to stop time, an adaptation of matt haigs forthcoming novel, whose film rights have been acquired by cumberbatchs production company. Sep 29, 2018 but then there are movies like the harry potter series.
You need to look at the deeper stories running through the book and use films ability to mess with time and perception. You need to look at the deeper stories running through the book and use film s ability to mess with time and perception. Casting a black and white adaptation of the joyce carol oates short story where are you going, where have you been for nyu. Commentary on where are you going, where have you been. Nov 01, 2018 downton abbey star teases upcoming film adaptation. Dec 22, 2019 greta gerwig on her little women film adaptation nprs michel martin speaks with. Sep 17, 2018 ready player one i loved the eragon and percy jackson books, and yes, the movies were horrible, but i could watch them. Little fires everywhere author celeste ng talks hulu.
A film adaptation is the transfer of a work or story, in whole or in part, to a feature film. As in the stephen king situation, you have to consider. Hong kong protesters how is it going on the front lines. A very part of what is challenging about it from a production standpoint is, you could do a very westernized version of shogun in the past, and now you have to make it really authentic. A short summary of joyce carol oatess where are you going, where have you been this free synopsis covers all the crucial plot points of where are you going, where have you been. Shogun readaptation with writer justin marks headed to. But then there are movies like the harry potter series. The story was loosely adapted into the 1985 film smooth talk, starring laura dern and treat williams. Why you shouldnt be mad if the movie adaptation of your. Screenwriter charlie kaufman, fresh off the success of being john malkovich, had a problem. Its regularly included in literary anthologies of great fiction, and was even adapted into a popular 1986 film, smooth talk, starring laura dern. As has been stated before, there are several reasons why directors choose to change the ending of a movie adaptation, such as artistic vision, cutting down or. They would not have fallen under this maniacs spell, after all. Another example would be the book pilgrims progress by john bunyan, an allegory about the christians journey from sin to redemption.
Booktofilm adaptations should be seen more like interpretations and everyone should enjoy the movie for what it is rather than what it shouldve been. What are some of your policies and if neccessary, how do. The beauty of adaptation is that you have no idea where its going to go next because the events are. Still from smooth talk, the film adaptation of joyce carol oatess where are you going, where have you been. Benedict cumberbatch is attached to star in how to stop time, an adaptation of matt haigs forthcoming novel, whose film rights have been acquired by cumberbatchs production company. In fact, a battle might be brewing between the author and film rights holder paramount. And since weve all been there, film adaptations of. Im not sure i would have enjoyed the film as much if it stayed the way it was for the first 30 minutes. It could have been assembled in a more linear fashion, but to be artsy, it had to be all jumbly. How faithful should book to film adaptations really be.
Going out of his mind with writers block, he eventually went off the deep end and wrote a. The story is set in 1960s america, a time when sexual mores were being questioned, adolescent sexuality hotly debated, and conventional roles for women challenged. If greens recent tweets are any indication, the looking for alaska film adaptation is not going well at all. Now we have a selfreferential film and, of course, its able to do a lot of stuff you cant do in a regular film, and they put it together brilliantly. And since weve all been there, film adaptations of beloved books. Is there ever going to be a film adaptation of neuromancer. Shogun readaptation with writer justin marks headed. Which film adaptation should have never been green lit. I think that the film would have been completely different. Ready player one i loved the eragon and percy jackson books, and yes, the movies were horrible, but i could watch them.
This new take on the world of alan moore and dave gibbons politically charged superhero satire is everything it should have been and so much more all but leaving the 2009 film adaptation in the dust. A scene in the film where connie hides from friend in her homes hallway was. My final input for a good film adaptation is a characters inner voice. There have been several attempts at bringing a movie adaptation to the big screen. What film adaptation was as good as or better than its source. The majority of the movie uses the same outline on which the short story is written from, as well as uses the same characters that are also used in the novel. I know some people disagree with me, but honestly i think that film could not have been made by anyone other than james cameron, and now that it has been made and its such a success, it proves. Information and translations of film adaptation in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. The movie script and editing is done in such a way that its supposed to seem like so wow and amazing. Opening moments of this adaptation of joyce carol oates story where are you going, where have you been with dern and friends doing the mallare realistic but nothing too original. Unfortunately, none of them seems to have succeeded. Oct 19, 2010 another example would be the book pilgrims progress by john bunyan, an allegory about the christians journey from sin to redemption. Based on the runaway bestseller, whered you go, bernadette is an inspiring comedy about bernadette fox academy award winner cate blanchett, a loving mom who becomes compelled to reconnect with.
Dec 16, 2011 james bond has been played by a variety of different actors featuring several different plotlines but has continued to be an extremely popular franchise with audiences. I think if you re going to make a movie out of this, you have to make a film to be read in the same way that botns is read. The film wanted to show what happens in a screenwriters head when she writes an adaptation. This ties in with the character, but the benefit of reading a. I too have always been amazed by all the things that are excluded from the movie but was in the book, when reading the book its almost impossible to. Sep 23, 2012 the movie script and editing is done in such a way that its supposed to seem like so wow and amazing. The story has also been cited as an inspiration for rose mcgowans 2014 short film dawn as well as the blood brothers 2003 song the salesman, denver max. What i mean is that it cant just be a conventional fantasyscifi epic. Oct 03, 2005 where are you going, where have you been. The first film adaptation of frankenstein has been. Im going to have to watch it again because the brilliance of it didnt even fully start to sink in until after i watched it. Literature film adaptation american university, washington, dc. Laura dern shines in a haunting joyce carol oates adaptation. Moores feelings towards adaptations of his work aside, hbos watchmen more than did right by his and gibbons classic dc comic book.
Yet the film is beloved as a classic, and many fans have forgotten or never knew it was an adaptation at all. Downton abbey star teases upcoming film adaptation. But the title is a pun, referring both to darwinian principle of adaptation and the ordeal of adapting a book into a screenplay. We should have been able to reach a stage in violence where we were just laughing at it. Two fifteenyearold girls, two finely honed styles, two voices, sometimes but not often overlapping. A critical history of film adaptation chapman university. Why you shouldnt be mad if the movie adaptation of your favorite book isnt 100 percent accurate. I think if youre going to make a movie out of this, you have to make a film to be read in the same way that botns is read.
An early draft of my short story where are you going, where have you been. Although often considered a type of derivative work, film adaptation has been conceptualized recently by academic scholars such as robert stam as a dialogic process. Adapting contemporary american fiction by women to film. Rating is available when the video has been rented. When characters on the page are made flesh on the screen.
Oates herself focused on this change when writing about the adaptation process for a new york times essay she wrote shortly after the films release. It was cast in a mode of fiction to which i am still. The film stars nicolas cage as kaufman and his fictional twin brother donald, meryl streep as susan orlean, and chris cooper as john laroche, with cara seymour, brian cox, tilda swinton, ron livingston, and maggie gyllenhaal in supporting roles. The first time i saw adaptation i expected something else and walked away severely disappointed. In the film smooth talk based on where are you going, where. Youre going to have tears you have julian fellowes, who won an oscar for writing, and hes done a great job with the story\.
If youve not read it before or if you only have a hazy memory of studying it at school id highly recommend you get yourself a copy or download it to your kindle. Pulitzer prizewinning novelist jeffrey eugenides discusses the. It is one of the marvelous visual features of the film that we see connie and her friends transform themselves. Similarly, george bluestone, whose 1957 study, novels into film has long been recognized as the basis for much film adaptation study, separates the experience of reading and watching as passive and active endeavors, clearly favoring the active. Hbo recently set the world of smallscreen comic book adaptations on fire with watchmen. It knows a bit more about itself than you probably do. Mar 09, 2015 why you shouldnt be mad if the movie adaptation of your favorite book isnt 100 percent accurate. Making a good adaptation is about using the language of film to convey what the language of literature doesnt or cant portray, says dussere. Jan 23, 2020 a very part of what is challenging about it from a production standpoint is, you could do a very westernized version of shogun in the past, and now you have to make it really authentic. Feb 19, 2016 if greens recent tweets are any indication, the looking for alaska film adaptation is not going well at all. Notably, there was one that was started in the mid1980s that involved tim leary, one that was worked on in the. At the core of oatess where are you going, where have you been.
The guardian and observers critics pick the 10 best in a very crowded field. The first film adaptation of frankenstein has been restored. The film adaptation of where are you going, where have you been. Andrew davies understands all too well the third main for a filmmaker tomake dramatic changes an adaptation, and it is one that anyone who works on. Sep 18, 2008 so you see how the movie could have been a doc. Oct 22, 2012 i think that the film would have been completely different. Her summer comes to a halt one afternoon where are you going, where have you been. And read up on the message boards here a bit to get a clearer grasp of whats going on if you re totally clueless. In the film smooth talk based on where are you going.
1177 44 1073 1399 445 286 221 1346 447 951 815 1478 1121 947 659 135 1035 486 625 745 706 766 1518 900 113 483 1252 45 257 386 174 667 487 1436